rockinlibrarian: (Default)
HAH! Check it out, Matilda made the list after all! And one spot PAST Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, even! Also I got quoted again, you might notice.

I'm interested in what she said about how this might have something to do with Matilda being one of Dahl's only female protagonists, and definitely the only one with her name in the title. The only others I can think of are Sophie in The BFG and the protag of The Magic finger whose name I can't even remember because I was never that into that one. And The BFG is my very close second-favorite Dahl, and I DID as a child have a weird thing about avoiding books with boy main characters-- though this didn't keep me from reading all Dahl's other books, boy-starring though they may be, perhaps the girl-issue DID subconsciously affect my favoritism....

In other news, it's beautiful outside, and Maddie cracks me up with her love of it. She is most definitely an outdoors person. I thought so last year, too, but it's even clearer now. She COMES TO LIFE outside. Which reminds me of-- I'm sorry, those of you who don't care-- another bookish Internet countdownish phenomenon going on right now, the School Library Journal's Battle of the Kids' Books. I link to that particular round of the battle because I'm mildly offended at some of the commenters' hatred slung at Calpurina Tate as they defend Fire, because while I don't doubt Fire is a very good book, Calpurina Tate IS my daughter so don't nobody be dissin' her book! I'm serious, she reminded me of Maddie when Maddie was only five months old. She's 11 months now and the similarity is even stronger if anything. Except Maddie has much more of an opportunity to actually grow up to be a naturalist!

That or a rock star. Is it wrong of me to totally want my daughter to be a rock star? NOT a pop singer, or a hip-hop or country or jazz artist, or opera singer; A ROCK STAR. thank you.

Date: 2010-03-18 11:28 pm (UTC)From: [personal profile] sal_amanda
sal_amanda: (Default)
Yes, a rock star. I concur.

Date: 2010-03-18 11:46 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] zimbra1006.livejournal.com
I had a feeling a few Dahls would make the list so I thought perhaps you were being too hasty in assuming Matilda wouldn't make it. It was my favorite too! One of my favorite childhood memories is of the summer I discovered it, lying in the tent on the deck with my brother (my mom allowed us to "camp out" all summer as long as we went no farther than the deck), taking turns reading it out loud to each other. (he was 3 years older than me, [obviously] a boy, and he loved it too). So I laughed when one of the comments they chose was about the girl and her sister tearing it in half fighting over it.. ha!

Date: 2010-03-19 08:29 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] rockinlibrarian.livejournal.com
More than a few-- five total (or so far?). It's just when I posted my worries originally only the top 25 books were left, and I'd been thinking Matilda was likely to rank in popularity somewhere closer to The Witches (which had already made the list quite low). If people know only about one Dahl book, it's Charlie; if they know about two Dahl books, they're Charlie and James. Therefore I figured once those two made the list, there'd be no hope for any other Dahl. Hooray for being wrong sometimes!

Date: 2010-03-22 01:56 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] onegradstudent.livejournal.com
Watching this list count down is so intense! (Is this what a nerd sport must feel like?)

Still, as always, hoping our dear Anne with an "e" will be number one.

Date: 2010-03-22 09:36 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] rockinlibrarian.livejournal.com
I'm glad you're enjoying it! Or, finding it as intense and exciting as I am!

Are you following it on your own or just when I mention it? Either way, you either know already or don't know and I'm telling you now that Harriet the Spy hit the list today at #16-- which I had figured would have been one of those unshakable Top Tenners. I've got my predictions list of the last books in no particular order because I can't figure out what order to put them in, and with HARRIET out of the Top Ten, well, part of me thinks what on earth WILL make the Top Ten, but the other part thinks Well that's more slots on the Top Ten OPEN, which makes Anne even MORE likely to be one of them! Not sure about number one, because maybe it's just a Girl Thing, but still, like I said before, my theory about Anne is that nobody doesn't LOVE her. Sure, lots of people may not like her, but everyone who DOES like her LOVES her, meaning everybody who likes her at ALL probably also VOTED for her, so she's bound to do well, right?

Profile

rockinlibrarian: (Default)
rockinlibrarian

January 2025

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 22nd, 2025 12:17 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios